Wine Advocate, 95 Points 

"The full-bodied 2012 Chardonnay reveals more buttery popcorn and honeysuckle characteristics, but there is no doubting the minerality, great fruit, super-freshness and 40+-second finish. Drink now through 2024." 

Wine Spectator, 94 Points 

"A dazzling effort that combines intensity with purity of flavor, depth, focus and persistence, offering a core of juicy apple, honeydew, citrus and meringue flavors, with vibrant tannins. Shows a hint of toasty oak on the finish, where this gains a measure of elegance and finesse."